E-book, Flash page flip, PDF - Which One is Best?

There is a lot of confusion out there about what constitutes a digital book or magazine and which format is preferable. Some references are to websites that call themselves magazines. I'm not going to slam that idea - if it gets them more hits, and they gain an audience for their information, great. But when I find one of those, I'm frequently disappointed, as I hoped for a less website-y (blocky, busy) and instead more coherent visual reading experience.

In this post, I'm going to sift through the muddy waters and give the picture I see of what's available to writers and publishers of content right now. I'll put in my two cents on what I think are the pros and cons of the options and at the end, let you know how CatStone Press can help with any of these options should you need consulting, design or enhancements.

Let's start with the most basic - a PDF document. Everyone knows about PDF because thankfully, it's become a standard for sending things to press. I love PDF because I remember before there WAS PDF and designers had to do way more packaging and worrying over print issues. PDF format is a wonderful thing. And yes, you can use this format to easily post on the web many of your documents. These can be viewed in some browsers, sometimes without download, but most frequently, when a viewer clicks on your PDF link, they will be required to download the document to their hard drive. The term "e-book" seems to often be tossed around for long pdf documents that are available for purchase (or free) on individual's websites. This is one format for self-publishing, but within publishing, it has the big drawback of not having much security in terms of digital rights management and is very freely passed around. 

One of the other main drawbacks of a PDF is the downloading of a potentially large file. (You also have to download Acrobat Reader, but that is so standard on computers today, that I wouldn't be too concerned about that.) Depending on the size of your document, that download can be a deal breaker for many readers. It can take a long while and it's now one more thing for a viewer to deal with on their own hard drive - unless you have readers wanting to retain a large digital file. If you include lots of images or rich media (yes, PDFs can contain media if you work it right) the file gets very large very fast. For small documents, this is a nice, easy, do-it-yourself method of putting up content on your site. Great for forms, small brochures, boring legal paperwork. As much as I hate paper, I'm happy our school puts up a nice visual yearly calendar in pdf form.

For large, visual, and rich media enhanced magazines and publications, I whole-heartedly endorse Flash page flip conversion (created using the likely large PDF files that come with these more complex documents.) Not only do I love this PF-Coverformat because it's our specialty, but also because this is an easy way to convert beautiful visual print assets into immediate digital assets that will retain the original design. You can enhance them easily with media while you're at it. It's going to play easily right on the pages and the file size added has a negligible effect on the reader. Flash publications also come with the ability to apply a strict Digital Rights Management environment if you want security with your document - either for selling, for tracking subscribers or for limiting the audience. Many of them can be created with a company that can package up an e-commerce solution as well should you want to sell your book or magazine.

Flash versions are good for handling media such as video, animations and audio within a format that looks like a magazine layout. You can create a great looking newsletter or digital brochure or catalog without learning web design or html. The Flash conversion hands you a simple url link that you can post on your website or in an email. The viewer clicks the link and boom, gets a whole reading experience right in the browser with no downloads required. 

One drawback to Flash editions is that these are not yet viewable on e-readers such as the Kindle or on Apple's iPhone or iPad. They ARE viewable on the newest tablets that are Android based.

And that brings us to the last format, e-books. 

sony-ebook"E-book" is starting to most commonly refer to file formats that are available for the new readers such as Kindle, Sony's Reader or the Nook. With the e-book format, you have the upside of getting quickly into the commercial mainstream with your text heavy content - for example, you can upload e-books directly to Amazon by using some of their partnering options. However, that content will need to be almost completely text as these readers are very limited in their ability to show any pictures or video, if showing them at all. A further setback for some publishers is that E-book formatting is itself an art form and comes with a learning curve if you want the chapters of your book and a Table of Contents to work well. 

CatStone Press is ready to help you with any of these formats and our specialty is in the design of great, visual, interactive publications such as magazines, annual reports and larger newsletters. However, we happily work with clients and projects of all sizes, whether you need design work from scratch or just enhancements to your base publication.


Thanks for reading! We welcome any comments about other formats or opinions on digital formats here. And please keep us in mind - CatStone Press is ready to help with any of these new digital formats, depending on the needs of your business or publication. Our design services are available for creating publications and documents from scratch or for helping you tweak your own documents to fit your desired format. Whether you'd just like help posting a PDF, want to make your magazine soar on the web, or would like help formatting your next e-novel, we're ready to help with your transition from paper to digital

CatStone Press  |   1310 Kenwood Lane, Charlottesville, VA 22901  |  434-960-0036